CBD Living vs Smoking Dog edibles looks like a head-to-head between two hemp brands, but the real question underneath it is simpler: do you want to feel intoxicated or not? That single decision separates these two catalogues more cleanly than flavor, format or price ever could, and getting it right on the first order saves an uncomfortable evening.
This comparison covers what each brand actually sells in the edible category, how the two approaches differ in practice, and which one makes sense as a starting point. If your interest is specifically evening wind-down rather than recreation, our CBD for sleep buying guide covers formats and strengths from that angle.
The one-line difference
CBD Living makes THC-free CBD products. Smoking Dog makes full spectrum, hemp-derived THC products. One is designed to be non-intoxicating; the other is explicitly designed to produce a buzz.
CBD Living: the THC-free edible shelf
CBD Living describes its range as THC-free premium CBD, spanning award-winning CBD water and sparkling water, edibles, topicals, CBD oil and a pet line. The edible side of the catalogue is built around two main formats.
The tinctures come in a wide ladder of strengths, from 300mg and 750mg up through 1500mg, 4500mg and 10,000mg, so you can start conservatively and move up only if you want to. They are taken directly under the tongue or mixed into food and drinks, and the brand uses a proprietary self-emulsifying technology to deliver oil-soluble ingredients in a water-compatible form. The gel capsules cover the other half of the shelf, in 750mg and 1500mg bottles, formulated with broad spectrum CBD, terpenes and Omega-3, -6 and -9 fatty acids for people who would rather not deal with a dropper at all.
There is also a pet range, with dog calming tinctures at 300mg, 600mg and 1000mg, and a topical line including the Freeze cold therapy roll-ons in 500mg, 1000mg, 2000mg, 4500mg and 10,000mg for anyone whose interest in hemp is more about a sore shoulder than an evening in. Our CBD Living review walks the whole catalogue.
Smoking Dog: full spectrum THC, and it does not hide it
Smoking Dog positions itself around premium full spectrum THC gummies and edibles, and the product names are refreshingly literal about it. The gummies come in Strawberry and Mango at 30mg of THC per gummy, 20 gummies per bottle, and the brand notes they are vegan, gluten-free and non-GMO, made with a proprietary self-emulsifying nanotechnology.
The drinkables are where the range really opens up. Seltzers run across a wide strength ladder: Yuzu Lime at 5mg per can, then Watermelon, Pink Lemonade, Orange Cream and a Mixed pack at 25mg, then Classic Cola, Root Beer and the Dr. Dawg soda-style flavor at 50mg, all sold in 12-packs. There is also a THC infused chocolate bar at 80mg, a Pink Lemonade shot at 100mg, and THC + CBD softgels with 3mg of hemp-derived Delta 9 THC and 25mg of CBD per capsule in a 30-count bottle. That last one is the closest thing to a bridge between the two brands.
Strength ladders are the most useful thing to compare
Both brands give you a range rather than a single option, but the ranges mean different things. With CBD Living, moving from a 300mg tincture to a 10,000mg one changes how concentrated each drop is, not whether you feel intoxicated, because the products are THC-free by design. With Smoking Dog, moving from a 5mg seltzer to a 50mg one is a meaningful jump in intensity, and the gap between the 5mg Yuzu Lime and the 100mg shot is enormous.
That is why a beginner's mistake with Smoking Dog is far more consequential than a beginner's mistake with CBD Living. If you are new to THC, the low end of the ladder exists for a reason. Our guide to choosing a THC strength walks through how to think about it, and the best Smoking Dog products guide covers the range itself.
Practical differences that decide it
Think about context, not just chemistry. CBD Living's tinctures and gel capsules fit a daytime routine, a workday, a commute, and anywhere you need to remain fully functional. Smoking Dog's seltzers and gummies are social and recreational products, closer in role to a drink than a supplement, and the brand's own framing of the buzz makes that plain.
Legality and testing matter too. Hemp-derived THC products are treated differently across states and countries, and travel rules can differ again. A THC-free CBD product travels through far more situations without complication, including workplaces that test. Whichever way you lean, buy from the brand's own store, check the strength on the label rather than assuming, and keep everything away from children and pets.
Format is worth thinking about separately from strength. A tincture lets you take a small amount and adjust the next day, which is why CBD Living's dropper bottles are the most forgiving thing on either shelf. A capsule removes the guesswork entirely but also removes the flexibility, since the dose is fixed at whatever the bottle says. A canned seltzer is the least adjustable of all: once it is open, you have committed to the can, which is why the 5mg and 25mg tiers exist rather than everything shipping at 50mg. And a chocolate bar or a shot is a portioning exercise, not a serving. Matching the format to how much control you want is usually more useful than agonising over milligrams.
Important cautions before you buy either
Neither brand's products are FDA approved, and neither is intended to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease. Nothing here is medical advice and none of these products should be treated as a substitute for care from a professional. Hemp compounds can interact with prescription medications, so talk to your doctor or pharmacist first, particularly if you are pregnant or nursing, managing a health condition, or taking anything regularly. With any THC product, never drive or operate machinery, and remember that edible effects arrive slowly, which is exactly how people end up taking more than they meant to. Follow the directions on the label.
The verdict
If you want an intoxicating experience with real control over intensity, Smoking Dog has the deeper and better-signposted ladder, from a 5mg seltzer all the way to a 100mg shot. But for most people asking this question for the first time, the safer and more flexible starting point is the non-intoxicating one. Browse the tinctures, capsules and topicals at CBD Living, start at the bottom of the strength range, and see how it fits your routine before you go anywhere near a stronger category.